Home

About Us 

The Proposal  

Issues

FAQs 

 Library

Links Contact Us

 

Become a mySun member | Login

Search: 

HOME | MARYLAND | NATION/WORLD | BUSINESS | SPORTS | ARTS/LIFE | OPINION | MARKETPLACE
Wind farms a problem, too
On the Bay: Tom Horton
Turbines: It would take thousands of these clean-energy, landscape-marring machines to generate only a slice of the region's power needs.
 
Recent columns

Little ponds, large impact
Feb 13, 2004

Going from less bad to a future of green
Feb 6, 2004

Deep winter chills island
Jan 30, 2004

Small tasks, large impact
Jan 23, 2004

Bay & Beach
Bay & Beach
Read about Ocean City, Assateague, Delaware beaches, the Eastern Shore, the Jersey shore and more or submit an unusual crab recipe or a fun beach snapshot to one of our contests and click through scenic photo galleries.
Related Articles

The Chesapeake Bay
Bay life pleases the eye and satisfies the soul.
May 1, 2002

More outdoors coverage

Map

Chesapeake Bay

Chesapeake Bay

In Depth

General Assembly coverage
Coverage of the 2004 legislative session.

College Guide
On Campus: Live & Learn
Our guide features profiles of Maryland's colleges and universities, campus photo galleries, event listings, student survival tips and more.
Free Alerts
We now offer free Breaking News Alerts via e-mail
Sign up here
Already registered? Login here
Also see
Originally published Feb 27, 2004
IREMEMBER climbing Maine's Cadillac Mountain, where day first breaks on the U.S. coast, to cover "Sun Day," celebration of a new era of renewable energy.

Maybe it was prophetic; the assembled politicians and environmentalists never saw the sun that overcast morning. There was some chanting, brief speeches, a dance to the sun, whiffs of marijuana on the breeze; and we all climbed down.

Soon after, President Jimmy Carter was gone, and Ronald Reagan put the solar panels on the Carter White House into permanent storage.

A quarter-century later, Maryland and other states are just getting serious about renewable energy. On Tuesday, the legislature will hear House Bill 1308, which would make utilities supply 7.5 percent of their electricity from renewable sources by 2014 (up from about zilch now).

You might assume environmentalists would be unanimously supportive. And indeed, from the Chesapeake Bay Foundation, concerned about air pollution's huge impact on the bay, to the Chesapeake Climate Action Network, working to reduce global warming, there's backing for HB 1308.

But many in Maryland's environmental community are genuinely torn about this issue.

On the one hand, this is what they've been hollering for for decades - a beginning to the end of reliance on foreign oil, as well as an antidote to dirty air, to destructive mining and drilling, to concerns about radioactive waste.

And yet, "clean" energy may be exacting more of an environmental price than necessary.

I spoke with Dan Boone, one of Maryland's finest naturalists, and a Sierra Club member who compellingly articulates the concerns (The club takes no official position on HB 1308).

The immediate issue is wind turbines, the overwhelming source of renewable power in the near future (an estimated 77 percent of renewable potential energy in the Mid-Atlantic).

It will take more than 2,000 turbines, each up to 450 feet tall, giant blades visible for miles, to make 7.5 percent of Maryland's electricity by 2030. For the entire Mid-Atlantic, it will take more than 12,000.

Generally located in clusters of dozens, or even hundreds, these so-called "wind farms," Boone says, "are actually major industrial facilities."

And they are largely exempt from any regulations that would minimize their environmental impacts, he notes. Two wind facilities visible from Maryland in Pennsylvania and West Virginia "have bulldozed the forests from huge tracts of mountain ridges," Boone says.

The one in West Virginia has also killed an estimated 3,000 bats and 1,000 birds in the past year - they fly into the turbine blades.

The Maryland bill creates a technical committee to deal with siting and other environmental impacts; but Boone notes it remains advisory only, applies only to facilities built in Maryland and exempts any that file applications to build by 2006.

Not addressed by anyone, he says, "is the scenic impact of all these wind turbines along high mountain ridges."

Expansive federal subsidies for wind energy are encouraging building "willy-nilly, without much regard for where the best wind potential is," Boone argues..

"Only 5 percent of the nation's wind potential is east of the Mississippi," Boone says. "So you have to ask, what are we sacrificing from our region's natural resources for a small fraction of that?"

And what if the hundreds of millions of dollars in subsidies to industrial-strength wind power were spent instead on using less energy - insulation, super-efficient appliances and lighting - at the business and homeowner level?

"The real 800-pound gorilla," Boone says, "is demand for electricity that grows 2.1 percent every year in Maryland, far faster than population grows."

Consider a recent Department of Energy study. It shows that nationwide, moving to 10 percent renewable energy would still see coal burning increase substantially - because of rapidly growing electrical demand.

Boone says while wind power is an improvement, once again we're going the route of heavily subsidizing major energy facilities, just as we've done with coal, oil and nuclear. "So how are we fundamentally going to change our wasteful ways?" he asks.

HB 1308 can't resolve all these issues. But one thing legislators could do is restore a provision to burn poultry manure for power.

Mountains of it on the Eastern Shore are a major bay pollutant. Even a modest energy facility could burn half of Maryland's chicken manure.

Vague concerns about air pollution from manure burning knocked it out of the bill. Given the huge potential to enhance water quality, it's worth trying to resolve such concerns without jettisoning manure as a renewable source.

Maybe HB 1308 can be improved to make it worth passing. But looking at the current state of wind power, even after waiting 26 years since Sun Day, I have an urge to go slowly.


Copyright © 2004, The Baltimore Sun | Get home delivery

Top baltimoresun.com headlines
For Edwards, Senate is a steppingstone


 





Enter to win tickets to movies, concerts, festivals, sporting events and more. This month's featured contest: Medieval Times.

Learn more about events sponsored by The Baltimore Sun and baltimoresun.com, including Smart Talk.

This month's featured section: Maryland Wedding.

Become a mySun member | Login

Search: